SMILER is a practical and comprehensive approach for developing a project's monitoring and evaluation system. It has been endorsed by TOPS, a technical-support agency funded by USAID.
In Malawi, Catholic Relief Services and eight partners used SMILER to design an M&E system for a five-year, $80-million program.
Download the PDF (331 KB)
Designing a system that works
Designing and implementing an effective monitoring and evaluation (M&E) system is crucial to a program’s success. M&E is a system to collect information that enables staff to measure progress and impact. With this information, staff can make evidence-based decisions about project activities and report meaningful results to donors.
If done well, M&E is the backbone of a project. If done poorly, M&E is a burden to all and provides useless information. The international relief and development community has invested heavily in evaluation activities (such as baseline and final surveys), but it has paid relatively little attention to the nitty-gritty tasks of setting up and implementing a useful monitoring system.
The CRS approach
To provide M&E guidance for projects, Catholic Relief Services created SMILER. It is a practical and comprehensive approach for developing a project’s M&E system. You can download it at http://www.crsprogramquality.org/publications/tag/propack/.
SMILER stands for simple measurement of indicators for learning and evidence-based reporting. Although M&E is rarely thought of as “simple,” SMILER breaks down the process into easily understood parts. It allows staff to collect, analyze and report on data in a systematic and productive way.
SMILER is endorsed by TOPS and approved for Food for Peace grantees. TOPS is a technical-support agency funded by USAID.
Spotlight on Malawi
In Malawi, staff from CRS and eight partners used SMILER to design an M&E system for a five-year, $80-million program called Wellness and Agriculture for Life Advancement. Staff successfully developed and implemented an M&E system for this complex program. By following the SMILER approach, staff set up methods for collecting all the required data through monitoring, assessments and evaluations.
The program uses the following M&E tools:
- surveys for data collection (baseline, annual and final)
- data flowcharts that are linked to data-gathering and reporting forms
- communication and reporting flowcharts for using data internally and reporting to stakeholders
- tools to continually assess and improve the quality of the service delivery and data
- a data management system for capturing key indicators and information on participants (without double counting)
The M&E system makes the program more efficient and effective. Project managers have an accurate census of the target population. They use this to track which members of which households participated in project activities. M&E staff collected information about eight diverse interventions to track progress and to define ways to improve the program.
While it is challenging to design and implement an M&E system in a complex operating environment, SMILER has proven to be an effective approach to develop a comprehensive and practical system.
CRS and partners were eager to get the project up and running quickly, but it takes time to set up an M&E system for a large, complicated project. To balance these priorities, managers learned the importance of their leadership roles in ensuring the integrity of the M&E system.
Staff want to achieve a seamless connection between the SMILER system and ICT4D (information and communications technologies for development). They are discussing how to better integrate the two.
Name of the program
Wellness and Agriculture for Life Advancement
$80 million from Food for Peace, Development Food Assistance Program
People the program is targeting
215,000 chronically food insecure households in five livelihood zones by 2014
For more information, contact firstname.lastname@example.org.
Publisher: Catholic Relief Services (April 2013)
Fact sheet: 2 pages
Dimensions: 8.5 x 11 inches
Posted on April 4, 2013